THE ENFORCEMENT
PROBLEM
UNMASKING THE REALITY ON BRITISH FARMS
In the eyes of many, the UK proudly wears the badge of a nation of animal lovers, championing some of the world's highest animal protection standards. However, as our co-authored report with Animal Equality reveals, the idyllic image often clashes with the stark reality for animals residing on British farms. Released in 2022, ‘The Enforcement Problem’ offers an unvarnished view of the challenges these animals face, uncovering a truth that demands our immediate attention and action.
In 2020, local authorities received 6,466 complaints relating to farmed animal welfare. Yet, fewer than 1% of complaints in 2018-2021 led to prosecutions.
The number of inspections was already low in 2018 and has decreased dramatically.
THE ENFORCEMENT PROBLEM UNVEILED
The 'Enforcement Problem' paints a grim picture: laws exist on paper but are severely under-enforced in practice, casting doubt on their effectiveness and relevance.
Our analysis of 65 investigations conducted between 2016 and 2021 unveiled alarming patterns. Each investigation unearthed some form of illegal activity, prolonged suffering and/or substandard practices. Shockingly, in 86% of these cases, the evidence was promptly handed over to relevant authorities. Yet, a staggering 70% of these instances saw no formal action taken. This isn't a mere oversight—it's a deeply concerning revelation exposing significant flaws in the enforcement system of farmed animal laws.
Furthermore, our data from freedom of information requests from the relevant public bodies, disclosed a startling reality: less than 3% of UK farms were inspected, translating to a meagre one inspection for every 205 farms. This abysmally low inspection rate raises profound concerns about the effectiveness of oversight. Less than 1% of animal welfare complaints resulted in prosecution. These shockingly low percentages vividly illustrate a system in disarray, failing to safeguard the well-being of these animals. Urgent action is needed.
A Call for Accountability
There are several bodies that enforce animal law creating confusion and diffusion of responsibility. You can see the players involved in the image above.
We pledge to hold all responsible authorities accountable. We will work to establish a robust framework to track successes, drive progress, applaud those demonstrating improvement, and spotlight areas in need of attention and enhancement. We will not rest until animal protection laws are robustly enforced.
Join us in the pursuit of a kinder world for all farmed animals. Together, we can mend a broken system and ensure the protection and welfare of farmed animals is properly upheld.